A federal court has stopped Oklahoma’s attempt to turn undocumented presence into a state-level crime. The ruling temporarily blocks a new law that would have allowed the state to jail non-citizens for being in Oklahoma without legal immigration status.
State Crackdown Paused by Federal Court
U.S. District Judge Bernard Jones issued a 14-day injunction against Oklahoma’s House Bill 4156, finding that the law likely violates the U.S. Constitution by stepping into the federal government’s exclusive domain over immigration. The ruling halts enforcement while legal challenges move forward, with a hearing set for early June to decide whether the block should be extended.
The challenged law empowers state and local law enforcement to arrest immigrants suspected of being in the country illegally. It criminalizes undocumented presence, making it a misdemeanor on the first offense, punishable by up to one year in jail and a $500 fine. A felony and a possible two-year prison term would follow a second offense. Those found guilty must depart the state within 72 hours of release or sentencing. Legal professionals have expressed concern that legislation such as HB 4156 may result in wrongful arrests, racial profiling, and uneven state-by-state enforcement. They warn that these measures may place lawful immigrants and U.S. citizens of color at risk of being swept up in broad crackdowns.
Immigrant Advocates Applaud Decision
The American Civil Liberties Union brought the lawsuit on behalf of Padres Unidos de Tulsa and several individual plaintiffs. Immigration advocates view the ruling as a significant win, especially for Oklahoma’s immigrant communities. They argue that the law would have placed thousands of people in legal jeopardy simply for their presence, bypassing federal standards and due process.
The Department of Justice had initially filed a suit against the state under the Biden administration, calling HB 4156 unconstitutional. That suit was later withdrawn after President Donald Trump took office. Still, Judge Jones emphasized that Congress intended immigration enforcement to be strictly a federal matter—regardless of who holds office.
State Officials Defend Enforcement Law
Oklahoma Attorney General Gentner Drummond criticized the decision as a blow to public safety. He argued that the law was a necessary tool for law enforcement to address issues like drug trafficking and cross-border crime. Supporters of HB 4156 believe the state has the right to protect its communities from undocumented individuals who, in their view, pose legal and social risks.
The bill’s supporting state lawmakers have voiced their displeasure with what they see as a dearth of federal border security action. They contend that in the absence of more stringent national immigration laws, local enforcement is crucial.
Federal Immigration Powers Continue to Be Paramount
The decision emphasizes the continuous tension between federal immigration policy and state-led immigration enforcement. Courts have repeatedly ruled that the federal government has jurisdiction over immigration regulation. Oklahoma runs the risk of enacting a patchwork of laws that are in opposition to both national policy and established legal precedents if it decides to criminalize undocumented status at the state level. Judge Jones reiterated that state-level sanctions cannot replace congressional and federal immigration agencies’ authority and that immigration laws must remain uniform.
What’s Next?
The injunction will remain in place until early June when a federal hearing will determine whether the block should be extended or lifted. The outcome could have national implications as other states consider similar enforcement efforts. For now, Oklahoma’s plan to criminalize undocumented immigrants has been put on hold—pending what promises to be a closely watched legal battle.
To stay up-to-date and informed, visit our news page, ask your immigration questions on Immigration Question, and get responses from licensed attorneys. For attorneys, streamline your case and lead management when you download the Immigration Question app.
